Big 4 Case Interview: Mistakes That Get You Cut

Big 4 Case Interview: Mistakes That Get You Cut

EY, Deloitte, PwC, and KPMG all run case interviews, and first rounds typically land three to five weeks after each application deadline.

In this session, MC coach Mitali Jalan, who worked at Deloitte and Bain before coaching 400+ candidates, walks through the three mistakes she sees cost Big 4 strategy candidates their offer.

The first is prepping only for 1-on-1 cases when these firms also run group, written, and presentation formats. The second is leaving behavioral prep until the night before, even though some firms weight it equally with the case. The third is practicing only with peers who can't see what a trained interviewer sees.

She also lays out the order to build readiness in – structure, math and brainstorming, business acumen, then firm-specific prep – and why skipping ahead costs you.

Black Belt is MC's flagship coaching program, built to close those gaps and get you offer-ready. Book a free 15-minute consultation with Katie to learn about your support options.

Land Your Big 4 Offer

  • Explore Black Belt – MC's flagship coaching program, with 1:1 case coaching from coaches like Mitali – 80% of clients land at least one offer.
  • Book a free consultation with Katie – 15 minutes to learn which support option fits your timeline and target firms

Free Big 4 Prep Resources

Recent Testimonials

Black Belt is great, definitely worth $2000 for an offer. Without coaching, I wouldn't know anything about how to nail my PEI. Highly recommend and don't be stingy on $2000 for a $200k job.

Dalton, Black Belt, McKinsey Offer

I hope this email finds you well...as an international student, I think I did well in the U.S. recruiting process, and want to thank you again for your effective coaching and kind support. It’s really nice getting to know you through the process. I look forward to staying in touch with you.

Aditi, BCG, McKinsey, and PwC Offers

Just wanted to mention I got the McKinsey offer! Thanks so much for all the help. I'm not sure who I will pick between BCG and McK, but I'm excited either way! Thanks so much for everything!

Derek, Black Belt Customer, McKinsey/BCG Offers

I've been at Bain for a year after using Black Belt - thank you!

Andrea, Black Belt Customer, Bain Offer

The final interview with McKinsey went well. The Head of the TLI Practice (Travel, Logistics & Infrastructure) called me after to say I will be getting an offer this afternoon!

Myles, Black Belt Client, Experienced Hire, McKinsey Expert Offer